I cant see bro which farmer is earning more. Bhai apke fantasy apne paas rakho. I belong to pace called rice bowl of Bihar ( Rohtas/ sasaram). What I know most farmers are marginalized farmers. The simple question why government is not implementing MS Swaminathan C2+50 per cent formula, which includes the input cost of capital and the rent on the land, to give the farmers 50 per cent of the returns.

To your knowledge around 65 countries in world witnessed farmer protests click here
...
more...

Also to your knowledge enchancement i have added 2 pictures AGRICULTURAL SUPPPORT AND MOST SUBSIDIZED economies , and you can see Where india is in Subsidy. Please talk on basis of facts.

And when the MSP of russia has become the benchmark for India, apart from that please tell how much population percent is involved in agriculture in Russia, Mr Putin does not brag in rallies that Farmers income will be doubled but in reality the farmer doesn't want to be his son to get involved in farming beacuse it is not profitable.



You will never able to grasp and understand the efforts of farmers, Just see a example farmer life

He purchased seeds paid to shopkeeper , shopkeeper earned revenue immediately.
He bought fertilizer , the shopkeeper earned revenue immediately.
He bought pesticides, the shopkeeper earned revenue immediately.
If monsoon fails he had to pay waterjet pump owner , he too make revenue immediately.

Now after doing this and all one day it rained and all cultivation went futile and you are keeping rant that farmers are making money.

ANSWERR IS BIG NO, PLEASE THOROW OFF YOUR : Bhakt ka chasma" . I have witnessed marriages being called-off due to crop failure and worse I have visited farmers in my neighborhood who committed suicides due to bad productivity and non payment of dues.


Just answer me why government is keen on bring what's not needed for the farmer, they have thousands if other issues like jobs, poverty healthy, diplomacy , defense.

waah.

Where i asked about benchmark of MSP in India mus be depend on Russia but at least it must be with international market.

If production price of any product in India...
more...

is more then selling price of same product in international market then how viable the production o that product?

Now coming to your examples of shopkeepers of fertilizers, seeds, pesticides etc. then you must know that if there is any loss for shopkeepers then no one will help but if there wil be loss for farmers, he will get compensation. If there is more revenue to shopkeeper, he needs to pay income tax but earning from farming is completely tax free.

Even after such liberties if farming is a cause of loss then time not to curse your KISHMAT, UPARWALA etc. Time to curse on your decisions.

If you cannot choose wisely that which product will give you more revenue and you yourself jump into loss making production then fault is at your end.

I agree with both of your pictures and wants to move towards solution as well but encouragement of a product for which production cost is already more then international market cost is completely illogical. Instead farmers should think about which crop can have low production cost then international market selling price so even if there are surplus production in country, government can export that crop.

Currently farmers want full independent on production and then MSP support from government which is fully illogical.

Ye tp wahi baat ho gayi ki mera man me jaha chaahu apna paisa lgaau aur agar revenue nahi mile to railway track par baith ke Sarkar se support maangu.