I don't understand why IR cannot Introduce New Trains in these short routes if they think there is a demand in these routes and availability of trains in these routes are less. For long distance routes u r giving to private players for comfortable journeys for passengers who can afford is okay. But still in long routes also IR can provide more modern trains why private is needed. But for short routes IR should introduce trains. According to me, SHM-RNC, HWH-BKSC, HWH-TATA none of these routes will get 100% occupancy, even HWH-PURI route except in festival seasons it will not get filled , see the situation of HWH-PURI Shatabdi running with poor occupancy except in pesk seasons.